Barometric Loops: A Forgotten Technology?

Boucle barométrique image

Today, backflow protection relies primarily on mechanical devices such as vacuum breakers or backflow prevention devices (BPDs). However, before these technologies became widespread, some installations used a purely hydraulic solution: the barometric loop. 

Rarely mentioned in modern guides, this technology relies on a surprisingly simple principle. It uses the height of a water column to physically block a water backflow, without any moving parts. No spring, no valve, no motor; just pipes and the laws of physics doing all the work. 

Is it still relevant today? 

What is a barometric loop and how does it work?

A barometric loop is a section of piping that rises or falls to a minimum of 35 feet (10.7 m) from the point of use [1]. Its function is to strictly prevent back-siphonage, which is a backflow of water caused by negative pressure in the system. 

Exemple d'application de boucle barométrique_Barometric loop application example

Figure 1: CSA B64.10 (DAr)\B64.10 - 2017

Even a perfect vacuum cannot support a column of water more than 33.9 feet (10.3 m) at sea level [1]. By creating a loop at least 35 feet high, we create an obstacle that siphonage cannot surmount. If a drop in pressure occurs upstream, the water cannot be pulled to the top of the loop, which prevents it from returning to the source of drinking water [5]. 

Why was it developed?

With the expansion of municipal water networks in the early 20th century, the potential for drinking water lines and non-potable sources to cross-contaminate increased significantly. Perhaps the most notable incident occurred in 1933. During the Chicago World's Fair, a faulty cross-connection contaminated the water supply shared by two hotels, which drew from a shared rooftop source, resulting in approximately 98 deaths and 2,000 cases of amoebic dysentery.

This incident led directly to the establishment of a research center focused on hydraulics and cross-connection control, as well as to an accelerated scientific study of backflow prevention [6].  

For a long time, the barometric loop was an attractive solution for protection against back-siphonage. At a time when mechanical backflow prevention devices were not well-developed, it offered protection that did not require any special maintenance nor involve any mechanical components needing periodic inspection.

Hôtels auditorium Chicago 1905_Auditorium Hotels Chicago 1905

Figure 2: Congress Plaza Hôtel et l'Auditorium Hôtel

Why is it less used today?

Despite its advantages, the barometric loop has been largely replaced by mechanical backflow prevention devices for several practical reasons. 

  • A clearance of 35 feet is not always available in the most modern buildings, unless you want to justify a 4-story stairwell for a simple piece of pipe. Its use is therefore limited to industrial settings or facilities specifically designed to accommodate it. 

 

  • Unlike backflow prevention devices, a barometric loop is not a certified manufactured product, but a custom-built piping configuration [2]. Confidence in its effectiveness therefore relies on the quality of its design, its installation and the necessary minimum height. Furthermore, its proper functioning cannot be verified through standardized periodic testing. This lack of verification represents a significant disadvantage at a time when cross-connection control programs increasingly rely on the inspection and traceability of installed devices [3] [4].

 

  • Since it does not cover hydrostatic counter-pressure, it’s at a disadvantage compared to devices such as other types of BPDs that handle both forms of water backflow simultaneously [1]. 
Station d’épuration des eaux usées_Waste water treatment plant

Figure 3: ‘Deer Island’ Wastewater Treatment Plant

In conclusion, despite these drawbacks, it still remains an attractive option in certain industrial settings where vertical space is not an issue, such as in water treatment plants.

References

[1] United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Cross-Connection Control Manual, Chapitre 4 — Methods and Devices for the Prevention of Backflow and Back-Siphonage 

[2] CSA Group. CSA B64.10-17/B64.10.1-17, Backflow Prevention Device Selection and Installation Manual. Toronto (ON): CSA Group, 2017. 

[3] City of Calgary. Frequently Asked Questions — Cross-Connection Control Program. 

[4] National Plumbing Code of Canada — provisions for barometric plumbing (CSA B64); U.S. Uniform/International Plumbing Code — similar definitions of barometric curb. 

[5] Hunter, R.B., Golden, G.E. et Eaton, H.N. (1938). « Cross-Connections in Plumbing Systems ». Research Paper RP1086, Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards, vol. 20. nvlpubs.nist.gov  

[6] American Society of Plumbing Engineers (ASPE). "National Backflow Prevention Day" — account of the 1933 Chicago cross-contamination incident. 

Figure [1] CSA B64.10 (DAr)\B64.10 - 2017

Figure [2] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Auditorium_Hotels,_Chicago_c._1905.png 

Figure [3] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Deer_Island_Waste_Water_Treatment_Plant_-_02.jpg 

Download the PDF version of this article below: